sábado, 6 de setembro de 2025

Strelets 005 - Army of Joan D'Arc

 (Para a versão em português, clique aqui)

This is one of my favorites (if not my favorite) sets from Strelets. I got 5 copies of this one (1 bought individually and 4 [almost complete sets] as a lot at an ebay auction).


The guys from PSR gave it a rating of only 6 for the sculpting, 7 for Historical Accuracy, 7 for Pose Quality and 8 for the Mould. The only 10 this set scored at the PSR website was for the pose number (which is indeed very good, since all 36 poses are unique). 

In my honest opinion, I'd have given a 9 or even a 10 for the sculpting and a 9 for the pose quality. 8 for the mould was kind of fair, due to the flash in a few places. 

As a fan of Strelets' work in general and an avid hobbyst colector of medieval miniatures, I thought the sculpting on this set was very good precisely because it has that "Strelets look" which is unique for this manufacturer. 

I personaly don't like "hyper-realistic" figures and I genuinely think that Strelets delivers in their sets a very nice balance between the "realistic look" and the "toy-ish look". Hence why I hesitate to buy those "perfect and ultra-realistic" 3d-printed minis that are popping up in ebay and other market places (mostly 28mm rpg minis, but still...) 


That being said, let me start with what I like about this set:

- this is a very nice looking set with the aforementioned "Strelets look". It is indeed very "Streletsy".


- This set provides a nice arrange of heavy infantry (or dismounted knights, or armored infantry if we use the Chainmail rules and jargon) which may be employed in any medieval european wargame army. 

- Also, the variety of armours is great too. You get a decent number of different helmets and armour styles in this set.




- There is also a good number of crossbowmen poses: 4 in total. A guy crouched, reloading his crossbow, another one with it rested in his shoulder (a good pose for a tower or wall sentinel, for example, or even to represent a marching crossbowman), one holding the crossbow as if waiting, and finally one shooting.


- I really like the short glaiveman (or perhaps they are Billmen?) with the very large shield. A group of these could work as "man-handled pavises", as in the picture below:





- A very useful piece is the king, which can be used as thus in any european medieval army (and also medieval fantasy armies)


 

- Another very useful piece in this set is the Herald figure, which is great to  compose a command group, for example. Also I think it is always nice when manufacturers provide civilian miniatures (specially priests, heralds and peasants) so that our games and dioramas have a greater variety of miniatures and thus more flavour. There should be more medieval civilian sets in 1/72. I'd buy, for sure!


- The horses are very beautiful on this set, specially the armoured ones. All the horse poses provided in this set are great.


Now the bad side:

- Since the French were known for their paladins / heavy knights, a higher number of such mounted figures could've been provided, and not only 6 mounted poses - and of those 6, 2 are mounted archers, 1 is Joan D'Arc herself and 1 is the King of France. Only 2 of the mounted poses in this set represent the famous french heavy cavalry, one with a sword and the other wielding a battle axe. The old Accurate / Revell "French Knights" set does it better by providing more knight poses. The French Warriors set from Italeri also does a good job. Obviously, all these sets may be used together to create a large French Army for the 100 years war.






- Some flash, specially in the edges of the small details (such as the herald's fleur-de-lis baton), which makes it more difficult to trim.

Overall, this is a very good set whether you are a wargamer and/or a collector of medieval niniatures. Even though this kit represents french soldiers and knights, I think these minis might be recruited by almost any other medieval european army, even those who have the fleur-de-lis design on their shields.

I really liked this dismounted knight! Perfect to represent a general or an officer!


Nenhum comentário:

Postar um comentário

This box art by LW

(Para a versão em Português, clique aqui ) I know that LW was (or still is? Does LW still exist?) a miniature manufacturer heavily criticize...